Federal workers sue over Elon Musk’s threat to fire them
The directive echoed how the billionaire entrepreneur has managed his own companies.
Billionaire Trump adviser Elon Musk violated the law with his demand that US federal employees explain their accomplishments or risk being fired, lawyers for the workers said in a lawsuit.
The updated lawsuit, which was filed in a federal court in California and was provided to the Associated Press, is trying to block mass lay-offs pursued by Mr Musk and President Donald Trump, including any connected to the email distributed by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) on Saturday.
The office, which functions as a human resources agency for the federal government, said employees needed to detail five things they did last week by end of the day on Monday.
“No OPM rule, regulation, policy, or programme has ever, in United States history, purported to require all federal workers to submit reports to OPM,” said the amended complaint, which was filed on behalf of unions, businesses veterans, and conservation organisations represented by the group State Democracy Defenders Fund.
It called the threat of mass firings “one of the most massive employment frauds in the history of this country”.
Mr Musk, who is leading the Republican president’s efforts to overhaul and downsize the federal government, continued to threaten federal workers on Monday even as confusion spread through the administration and some top officials told employees not to comply.
“Those who do not take this email seriously will soon be furthering their career elsewhere,” Mr Musk posted on X, his social media platform.
He also escalated Mr Trump’s demand for employees to stop working remotely, saying those who fail to return to the office will be placed on administrative leave.
The latest round of turmoil began over the weekend, when Mr Trump posted on his social media website: “Elon is doing a great job, but I would like to see him get more aggressive.”
Mr Musk followed up by saying “all federal employees will shortly receive an email requesting to understand what they got done last week”. He claimed “failure to respond will be taken as a resignation”.
The directive echoed how the entrepreneur has managed his own companies.
The Office of Personnel Management sent out its own request afterwards.
“Please reply to this email with approx. 5 bullets of what you accomplished last week and cc your manager,” the message said. However, it said nothing about the potential for employees being fired for noncompliance. The deadline was listed as 11.59pm on Monday.
There was swift resistance from several key US agencies led by the president’s loyalists — including the FBI, the State Department, Homeland Security and the Pentagon — which instructed their employees over the weekend not to respond.
Politicians in both major parties said Mr Musk’s mandate may be illegal.
One message on Sunday morning from the Department of Health and Human Services, led by Robert F Kennedy Jr, instructed its 80,000 employees to comply. That was shortly after the acting general counsel, Sean Keveney, had instructed some not to.
And by Sunday evening, agency leadership issued new instructions that employees should “pause activities” related to the request until noon on Monday.
“Having put in over 70 hours of work last week advancing administration’s priorities, I was personally insulted to receive the below email,” Mr Keveney said in an email that acknowledged a broad sense of “uncertainty and stress” within the agency.
Mr Keveney laid out security concerns and pointed out some of the work done by the agency’s employees may be protected by lawyer-client privilege.
Democrats and even some Republicans, including senator John Curtis of Utah, were critical of Mr Musk’s ultimatum.
“If I could say one thing to Elon Musk, it’s like, ‘Please put a dose of compassion in this’,” Mr Curtis, whose state has 33,000 federal employees, said. “These are real people. These are real lives. These are mortgages… It’s a false narrative to say we have to cut and you have to be cruel to do it as well.”
New FBI director Kash Patel, an outspoken Trump ally, instructed employees to ignore Mr Musk’s request, at least for now.
“The FBI, through the Office of the Director, is in charge of all of our review processes, and will conduct reviews in accordance with FBI procedures,” Mr Patel wrote in an email. “When and if further information is required, we will co-ordinate the responses. For now, please pause any responses.”
Ed Martin, interim US attorney for the District of Columbia, sent his staff a message on Sunday that may have caused more confusion.
“Let me clarify: We will comply with this OPM request whether by replying or deciding not to reply,” Mr Martin wrote in the email.
“Please make a good faith effort to reply and list your activities (or not, as you prefer), and I will, as I mentioned, have your back regarding any confusion,” Mr Martin continued. “We can do this.”
Officials at the departments of state, defence and homeland security were more consistent.
Tibor Nagy, acting undersecretary of state for management, told employees in an email that department leadership would respond on behalf of workers.
Pentagon leadership instructed employees to “pause” any response to Mr Musk’s team, according to an email from Jules Hurst, the deputy undersecretary of defence for personnel and readiness.
The Homeland Security Department, meanwhile, told employees that “no reporting action from you is needed at this time” and that agency managers would respond, according to an email from RD Alles, deputy undersecretary for management.
Thousands of government employees have been forced out of the federal workforce — either by being fired or through a “deferred resignation″ offer — during the first month of Mr Trump’s second term.
There is no official figure available for the total firings or lay-offs, but the AP has tallied hundreds of thousands of workers who are being affected. Many work outside of Washington.
Mr Musk on Sunday called his latest request “a very basic pulse check”.
“The reason this matters is that a significant number of people who are supposed to be working for the government are doing so little work that they are not checking their email at all!” Mr Musk wrote on X.
